AthleteWiki
Live
FOOTBALLXavi Xavi Embraces Netherlands Challenge With Immediate ContactFOOTBALLSilva Bernardo Silva Explains Why He Chose Real MadridFOOTBALLTorres Ferran Torres fires PSG to first Ligue 1 win with decisiveFOOTBALLHaaland Erling Haaland's Controversial Derby Winner PromptsFOOTBALL (Lawrence Trevor Lawrence's 4-TD Week 1 Performance Sparks JaguarsWRESTLINGMorgan Liv Morgan Loses Women's World Title to Stephanie VaquerFOOTBALLXavi Xavi Embraces Netherlands Challenge With Immediate ContactFOOTBALLSilva Bernardo Silva Explains Why He Chose Real MadridFOOTBALLTorres Ferran Torres fires PSG to first Ligue 1 win with decisiveFOOTBALLHaaland Erling Haaland's Controversial Derby Winner PromptsFOOTBALL (Lawrence Trevor Lawrence's 4-TD Week 1 Performance Sparks JaguarsWRESTLINGMorgan Liv Morgan Loses Women's World Title to Stephanie Vaquer

Phil Foden vs Scott McTominay

One page, two careers: trophies, records, net worth and everything else that settles the argument.

Phil FodenPhil Foden Scott McTominayScott McTominay
FootballSportFootball
EnglandNationalityScotland
28 May 2000Born8 December 1996
1.71 m / 5 ft 7 inHeight1.91 m / 6 ft 3 in
$57MNet worth$15M
10Major honours5
3Records0

Career Numbers

369Total Club Appearances-
110Total Club Goals-
49Total International Caps-
4Total International Goals-
-Total appearances408
-Total goals71
-International caps73
-International goals15

Honours Side by Side

Phil Foden (10)

  • FIFA U-17 World Cup
  • UEFA European Championship
  • UEFA European Under-17 Championship
  • Premier League
  • FA Cup
  • EFL Cup

Scott McTominay (5)

  • FA Cup
  • EFL Cup
  • Serie A
  • Most Valuable Player
  • Ballon d'Or nomination

The Case for Each

Phil Foden brings the heavier trophy cabinet: 10 documented honours against 5 for Scott McTominay. Silverware is not the whole story, but it is the first line of any football argument.

On records, Phil Foden holds 3 documented marks to 0 for Scott McTominay. The headline entry: Youngest Premier League winner. Records show peaks; honours show sustained dominance. The two lists rarely agree on a winner, which is exactly why this debate refuses to die.

Football is the world's game, played and watched by billions across every continent. Its biggest stars carry entire nations on their shoulders, from World Cup finals to Champions League nights. No sport produces global icons at the same rate, and no debate burns hotter than who stands above the rest. That backdrop is what makes a matchup like this one resonate beyond the box scores.

Scott McTominay is the senior figure by roughly 4 years, which frames the comparison: one career is closer to its final shape, the other still has chapters to write.

Commercially, Phil Foden leads with an estimated $57M net worth. Earning power tracks fame more than form, but it is part of the legacy question.

For the complete record, see Phil Foden and Scott McTominay, both updated daily with stats, honours and news on AthleteWiki.

Full profiles: Phil Foden · Scott McTominay