Juan Soto Draws Hustle Criticism, DH's as Mets Host Phillies

Juan Soto is the designated hitter for the New York Mets as they open a four-game series against the Philadelphia Phillies at Citi Field on Thursday, September 17. The Mets, eliminated from playoff contention, are looking to play spoiler against a Phillies team holding the second NL Wild Card spot.

Soto's Role and Performance in a Lost Season

Soto moves to DH after playing several games in left field, batting second between Francisco Lindor and Bo Bichette. His 2026 campaign has been solid but interrupted. He has played 101 games, batting.271 with 25 home runs, 61 RBI, and a 153 OPS+. A nasty calf issue early on coincided with the Mets' struggles, though his offensive output remains elite.

Analyst Calls Out Soto's 'Lack of Hustle'

Dan Clark of Dan Clark Sports criticized Soto's effort during the recent Subway Series in the Bronx. Clark pointed to a game-ending double play on Friday and a play Saturday where Soto was tagged out on what could have been an error. "His lack of hustle on Friday night resulted in a game-ending double play," Clark wrote. "$765 million. What a disgrace." Soto did homer in the series' second game, a 12-2 Mets win.

Broadcaster Dismisses Soto's Ted Williams Comparisons

Veteran WFAN broadcaster Joe Benigno delivered a blistering take, dismissing comparisons between Soto and Boston Red Sox legend Ted Williams. "I'm putting it right out there... This guy (Pete Alonso) is having a much better year than the overrated Juan 'freaking' Soto," Benigno said. "And if I hear again that this guy is Ted Williams, I'm gonna vomit." He questioned Soto's clutch hitting, saying he'd prefer other Mets in big spots.

Soto Shows Love to Dodgers Prospect Josue De Paula

Away from the criticism, Soto recently showed support for Los Angeles Dodgers top prospect Josue De Paula. Soto posted a clip of De Paula on his Instagram story, calling him "el loco mio." The two share roots at the "El Niche" academy in the Dominican Republic and are both represented by Boras Corporation. Viral comparisons have noted similarities in their batting stances, though De Paula said his version wasn't a direct imitation of the Soto Shuffle.

The Financial Profile of a Modern Superstar

Soto's financial standing was cemented by his historic 15-year, $765 million contract with the Mets in December 2024. The deal includes a $75 million signing bonus and an opt-out after 2029. Celebrity Net Worth estimates it could reach $805 million with escalators. This sets him apart in the game's financial elite.

• KEY TAKEAWAYS: Soto is DHing for the Mets on September 17. He faces scrutiny for perceived effort issues from analysts. His massive contract remains a benchmark for player earnings. He maintains a mentoring connection with young star Josue De Paula.