Cam Newton challenges Josh Allen’s No. 1 QB ranking over Patrick Mahomes

Cam Newton has fired back at Josh Allen’s new ranking as the NFL’s No. 1 quarterback, arguing Patrick Mahomes’ resume makes him the league’s undisputed top player. The former MVP criticized Allen’s placement ahead of Mahomes in a recent survey of NFL executives, scouts, and coaches, pointing to Mahomes’ three Super Bowl titles and MVP honors as proof of his superiority.

What sparked the debate?

The controversy stems from a pre-season survey where Allen edged out Mahomes for the top QB spot. Newton, speaking on the 4th&1 podcast, called out Allen’s inconsistency, saying, ‘If you’re the No. 1 QB, you’re supposed to be the reason we win, not why we lose.’ He highlighted Allen’s struggles in last season’s playoff loss to Denver, contrasting it with Mahomes’ clutch performances in high-stakes games.

Why does Patrick Mahomes stand out?

Newton emphasized Mahomes’ unmatched achievements, including three Super Bowl wins and multiple MVPs. ‘Josh Allen don’t get the blame like everybody else,’ Newton said, noting Allen’s lack of a Super Bowl appearance despite his talent. Mahomes, at 29, has already cemented his legacy as one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history, while Allen, now 30, remains title-less.

What’s next for Allen and Mahomes?

As the 2026 season approaches, Allen faces pressure to prove he belongs atop the QB rankings. Mahomes, meanwhile, will aim to add to his trophy case with the Chiefs. Newton’s critique underscores the high expectations for Allen, who must now deliver where Mahomes has consistently succeeded.